Cracking The Code
Not Every Cycle Creates a Stronger Code
by Megan Headley
“They are trying to say ‘these are
the line items that are costing the insurance industry the most, and
there are really big improvements we have to make there, and here are
some things that we spend a huge amount of money to build each home
on and we’re not seeing any failures there.’” —Dean Ruark, PGT Industries
Building professionals are often quick to point out that
the building codes are the weakest degree to which a building legally
can be built. That is one reason programs such as the U.S. Green Building
Council’s LEED standards are so popular: they give guidance for achieving
a higher level of building efficiency and make it popular for builders
and owners to go beyond what is required.
That’s also a reason why the Insurance Institute for Business & Home Safety’s
claim in August 2013 that some states in hurricane-impacted areas were
weakening their state codes raised concern among building professionals.
In taking a look at these changes, however, glass professionals are asking:
is an older code always a weaker code?
“In some cases, an older code may be more stringent than the newer code,”
says David M. Rinehart, North America protective glazing marketing manager
for DuPont Glass Laminating Solutions in Wilmington, Del.
One of the bigger changes impacting the International Building Code (IBC),
and many states’ individual codes, was the 2012 IBC’s incorporation of
the latest version of ASCE 7, Minimum Design Loads for Buildings and Other
“The new version of ASCE 7-10 defines the wind speeds, and therefore the
design pressures for buildings, and where you need impact-resistant products,”
explains Dean Ruark, code compliance manager for PGT Industries, an impact-resistant
window manufacturer with headquarters in Venice, Fla., and an office in
N.C. (see July 2011 USGlass, page 22, for more on ASCE 7-10).
Among other changes, the most up-to-date ASCE 7 increases the regions
that are included within wind zone 4, Rinehart explains. “In previous
versions, wind zone 4 covered Miami Dade and Broward Counties in Florida,
as well as Monroe and parts of Palm Beach County, Fla., and some regions
of Louisiana. With the changes to ASCE 7-10, the wind contour line moved
a little bit, and in that remapping of the wind contour line it included
about a third of Conyers County in Florida (which includes both Naples
and Marco Island), and in the Mississippi-Delta region it included more
of Louisiana. It also included the three counties along the Mississippi
Gulf Coast, as well as Mobile County in Alabama,” Rinehart says. He speculates
that the drastic remapping may have been part of the reason why in 2013
Louisiana approved an Emergency Declaration by the State Code Council,
adopting the 2012 edition of the IBC design wind speed maps, but omitting
the trigger for following high-wind design requirements (this has since
changed—more on that below).
For Florida, it’s “status quo” for this code cycle since the state already
had adopted the new ASCE 7 standard (see
page 18). That means Florida already has had a preview of what could
happen when the new I-codes are adopted. “Everyone got worried and it
changed markets, and everyone else will have to deal with that once they
adopt this I-Code,” Ruark says.
Right now, says Gary Orman, president and CEO of Innovative Window Corp
in Boynton Beach, Fla., “It’s hard to tell what the changes are going
to affect or not affect.”
When IBHS rated the progress made by the 18 most hurricane-prone coastal
states along the Gulf of Mexico and the Atlantic Coast in strengthening
their residential building codes in 2013 (an updated report will be issued
in 2015), the institute declared, among other things, that North Carolina
and Louisiana had weakened provisions.
Since that time, Louisiana has adopted the 2012 editions of the I-codes,
with Louisiana-specific amendments, leaving North Carolina on the chopping
block. Although North Carolina has amended and adopted the 2009 editions
of the I-Codes as the 2012 North Carolina State Building Code, it also
enacted legislation that changed the adoption cycle for I-Codes from every
three years to every six years.
Will this particular change have any real impact on the security of buildings
along the coastline?
“I don’t think the change from a three year to six year cycle will have
any significant effect,” says Paul Beers, managing member of Glazing Consultants
International in West Palm Beach, Fla. He adds, however, that it’s glazing
contractors who are unlikely to see any impact. North Carolina’s “weakened”
code, as laid out by IBHS, may be more geared toward residential construction.
“My experience of late has been that informed homeowners will seek out
impact-rated glazing for insurability reasons. Quality wind insurance
has become very difficult to acquire and without proper impact protection,
it makes things even worse. Some of [North Carolina’s] changes may help
those who are solely focused on a low construction cost get by with inadequate
or no impact protection,” Beers says, adding, “This will all depend upon
if and how the code is enforced by local jurisdictions in coastal areas.
If the 2009 IBC was adopted, then impact-rated systems are required in
Ruark adds, “IBHS is making the point that we might change some things
that are found to be instrumental and we want to get them in place … So
I would say it has the potential to weaken the code to not get a major
change through as quickly.”
Ruark further suggests that the IBHS’ concern reflects the research being
done on hurricanes’ impact of insurance and construction costs. “They
are trying to say ‘these are the line items that are costing the insurance
industry the most, and there are really big improvements we have to make
there, and here are some things that we spend a huge amount of money on
to build each home and we’re not seeing any failures there. Maybe we’re
doing it right or maybe we’re overdoing and there’s some research that
says we can spend money in places that make a little more sense,’” Ruark
What’s Enforced Where?
While the 2013 IBHS report focused on encouraging states to do more to
protect their residents from hurricanes, it noted that many states have
stepped up to adopt, and better enforce, the 2012 IBC. For example, in
2013 Maryland enacted a law preventing local jurisdictions from weakening
statewide wind design and windborne debris requirements. New York City
adopted its own code based on the 2009 edition of the IBC, set to go into
effect in October 2014, moving the rest of the state toward updated codes.
Following the IBHS report, Mississippi signed into law an act to adopt
one of the last three adopted editions of the IBC and other relevant codes
as of August 1, 2014.
So how does this affect glass companies?
To some degree this depends less on what the code says and more on how
it is enforced.
“We heard a lot of buzz right after Hurricane Sandy [in October 2012]
and a lot of folks asked ‘are you going to see a much bigger market?’”
Ruark says. The answer to that question is still “no.” Ruark explains,
“We haven’t seen major changes yet. We do sell some impact-resistant product
along the Eastern seaboard, but it sure hasn’t gained the traction that
Florida has. I think a part of it has to do with enforcement of the code
because it really is already required up there in some instances.”
“In general, codes are very well enforced. However, it depends on the
area,” says Steve Dawson, executive vice president of sales for CGI Windows
and Doors Inc. in Miami. “We find the best course is to follow the code
to avoid any issues.”
But with all of these changes and piecemeal code adoption, it can be difficult
to keep track of what code is required where.
“Most of our glazing contractors have no idea there’s a code change even
coming,” Orman finds.
As Ruark puts in, there are glazing contractors who are on top of each
code cycle, who are reaching out to product manufacturers for updated
code guidance well before adoption day. “They’re the minority,” he says.
“I’d say the majority in Florida, simply because of the [strict] enforcement,
want to know the big changes very quickly after the updated code comes
“Some of the glazing contractors are pretty proactive,” Rinehart agrees,
“but many can be confused when code changes occur.”
To keep abreast of code changes as they arise, Dawson advises, “Join the
trade organizations in your area that monitor these. Participate in the
state code meetings and conference calls when changes are being discussed.”
Megan Headley is special projects editor for USGlass
magazine. She can be reached at firstname.lastname@example.org.
© Copyright 2014 Key Communications Inc. All rights reserved.
No reproduction of any type without expressed written permission.